Skip to content
Craft-A-CROPolis is coming October 2025! Sign up today at www.maymayevents.com
  • New Products
  • Gift Cards
  • Maymay's Stamp List
  • Customer Gallery
  • Maymay Events

Need help?

Call us 205-755-3465
info@maymaymadeit.com

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • TikTok
  • Shop Products
  • All Products
  • Albums
  • Bibles, Books & Stationery
  • Crafting Storage
  • Maymay's T-Shirts & More
  • Free Files
  • Free SVGs
  • Free PDF Files
  • Blog
  • Maymay Made It Blog
  • Maymay Sewed It Blog
  • Join the Stamp Club
  • Stamp of the Month Club (US)
  • Stamp of the Month Club (outside US)
  • Scripture Stamp of the Month Club (US)
  • Scripture Stamp of the Month Club (outside US)
  • Adhesives
  • Art Glitter Glue
  • Foam Tape
  • Mod Podge
  • Sticky Tape
  • Yellow Tape
  • And More!
  • Brands
  • Maymay Made It
  • 49 and Market
  • Art Glitter Glue
  • American Crafts
  • Basic Grey
  • Brutus Monroe
  • Carta Bella
  • Craft Consortium
  • Crafter's Companion
  • Creative Expressions
  • Cricut
  • Doodlebug
  • Dress My Craft
  • Echo Park
  • EK Success
  • Elizabeth Craft Designs
  • Fiskars
  • Grafix
  • Graphic 45
  • Hampton Arts
  • Jolee's Boutique
  • Lawn Fawn
  • M'pressables
  • Maymay's Ink Bandit
  • Mintay Papers
  • My Sweet Petunia {Misti}
  • Nuvo
  • Paper Accents
  • Photo Play
  • Plaid & FolkArt
  • Prima Marketing
  • Prismacolor
  • Riley Blake
  • Scrapbook Adhesives
  • Simple Stories
  • Sizzix
  • Spellbinders
  • Surebonder
  • Tim Holtz
  • Tonic Studios
  • Waffle Flower
  • We R Memory Keepers
  • Coloring & Paints
  • Markers
  • Paints
  • Pencils
  • Watercolor
  • And More!
  • Die Cutting
  • Dies
  • Embossing Folders
  • Machines
  • Plates & Accessories
  • And More!
  • Embellishments & Stickers
  • Bling
  • Drops
  • Ephemera and Doilies
  • Foil
  • Metal Embellishments
  • Rub-Ons
  • Stickers
  • Twine and Trims
  • And More!
  • Embossing
  • Folders
  • Powders
  • Ink
  • Tools
  • And More!
  • Inks
  • Dye
  • Pigment
  • Distress
  • Embossing
  • Permanent
  • Refills
  • And More!
  • Paper - Cardstock - Chipboard
  • Paper and Cardstock
  • Chipboard
  • Cards and Envelopes
  • 49 and Market
  • American Crafts
  • Brutus Monroe
  • Carta Bella
  • Craft Consortium
  • Doodlebug Designs
  • Echo Park
  • Grafix
  • Graphic 45
  • Lawn Fawn
  • Mintay
  • Paper Accents
  • Photo Play
  • Prima Marketing
  • Simple Stories
  • Sizzix
  • And More!
  • Stamping
  • Maymay Mini
  • Maymay 4x4
  • Maymay 4x6
  • Maymay 6x6
  • Maymay 6x8
  • Maymay Monogram
  • Maymay Scripture
  • Maymay Vault
  • M'pressables
  • Stamp Cleaners
  • Stamping Tools and Accessories
  • And More!
  • Tools
  • Address-a-lopes
  • Craft Knives & Blades
  • Crimper
  • Cutting Mats
  • Magnets
  • Pens & Markers
  • Punches
  • Punch Boards
  • Replacement Blades
  • Rulers
  • Scissors
  • Trimmers
  • Wax Melts & Seals
Maymay Made It Maymay Made It
Country/region
Login / Signup
My account

Login to my account

Enter your e-mail and password:

New customer? Create your account

Lost password? Recover password

Recover password

Enter your email:

Remembered your password?

0
Cart

Your cart is empty

Shop our products
  • New Products
  • Shop Products
    • All Products
    • Adhesives
      • Art Glitter Glue
      • Foam Tape
      • Mod Podge
      • Sticky Tape
      • Yellow Tape
      • And More!
    • Albums
    • Bibles, Books & Stationery
    • Brands
      • Maymay Made It
      • 49 and Market
      • Art Glitter Glue
      • American Crafts
      • Basic Grey
      • Brutus Monroe
      • Carta Bella
      • Craft Consortium
      • Crafter's Companion
      • Creative Expressions
      • Cricut
      • Doodlebug
      • Dress My Craft
      • Echo Park
      • EK Success
      • Elizabeth Craft Designs
      • Fiskars
      • Grafix
      • Graphic 45
      • Hampton Arts
      • Jolee's Boutique
      • Lawn Fawn
      • M'pressables
      • Maymay's Ink Bandit
      • Mintay Papers
      • My Sweet Petunia {Misti}
      • Nuvo
      • Paper Accents
      • Photo Play
      • Plaid & FolkArt
      • Prima Marketing
      • Prismacolor
      • Riley Blake
      • Scrapbook Adhesives
      • Simple Stories
      • Sizzix
      • Spellbinders
      • Surebonder
      • Tim Holtz
      • Tonic Studios
      • Waffle Flower
      • We R Memory Keepers
    • Coloring & Paints
      • Markers
      • Paints
      • Pencils
      • Watercolor
      • And More!
    • Crafting Storage
    • Die Cutting
      • Dies
      • Embossing Folders
      • Machines
      • Plates & Accessories
      • And More!
    • Embellishments & Stickers
      • Bling
      • Drops
      • Ephemera and Doilies
      • Foil
      • Metal Embellishments
      • Rub-Ons
      • Stickers
      • Twine and Trims
      • And More!
    • Embossing
      • Folders
      • Powders
      • Ink
      • Tools
      • And More!
    • Inks
      • Dye
      • Pigment
      • Distress
      • Embossing
      • Permanent
      • Refills
      • And More!
    • Paper - Cardstock - Chipboard
      • Paper and Cardstock
      • Chipboard
      • Cards and Envelopes
      • 49 and Market
      • American Crafts
      • Brutus Monroe
      • Carta Bella
      • Craft Consortium
      • Doodlebug Designs
      • Echo Park
      • Grafix
      • Graphic 45
      • Lawn Fawn
      • Mintay
      • Paper Accents
      • Photo Play
      • Prima Marketing
      • Simple Stories
      • Sizzix
      • And More!
    • Stamping
      • Maymay Mini
      • Maymay 4x4
      • Maymay 4x6
      • Maymay 6x6
      • Maymay 6x8
      • Maymay Monogram
      • Maymay Scripture
      • Maymay Vault
      • M'pressables
      • Stamp Cleaners
      • Stamping Tools and Accessories
      • And More!
    • Tools
      • Address-a-lopes
      • Craft Knives & Blades
      • Crimper
      • Cutting Mats
      • Magnets
      • Pens & Markers
      • Punches
      • Punch Boards
      • Replacement Blades
      • Rulers
      • Scissors
      • Trimmers
      • Wax Melts & Seals
    • Maymay's T-Shirts & More
  • Gift Cards
  • Free Files
    • Free SVGs
    • Free PDF Files
  • Maymay's Stamp List
  • Blog
    • Maymay Made It Blog
    • Maymay Sewed It Blog
  • Join the Stamp Club
    • Stamp of the Month Club (US)
    • Stamp of the Month Club (outside US)
    • Scripture Stamp of the Month Club (US)
    • Scripture Stamp of the Month Club (outside US)
  • Customer Gallery
  • Maymay Events

Frequently Asked Questions

I made a mistake in my order, wrong address, forgot coupon code, etc.  Can you edit my order after it is placed?

No, unfortunately once an order is placed and submitted we cannot edit it.  Please double check your information before submitting your order.

I placed my order and want to add something to it, can I do that?

No, unfortunately once an order is placed and submitted we cannot edit it.

If I placed two separate orders can shipping be combined?

No, unfortunately once an order is placed and submitted we cannot edit it.

I wanted to use two coupons codes, can I stack them?

No, the shopping cart only accepts one code at a time.  We suggest using the code that will result in you receiving the best discount.

I was shipped the wrong or damaged item, how do I return it to get this correct?

Please send an email to info@maymaymadeit.com and we will start the return/exchange process for you.

Returns or damaged items, you have 30 days to return from the date you received it.

To be eligible for a return on items ordered/shipped incorrectly, the item must be unused, and in the same condition that it was received. Your  item must be in original packaging.

Do you restock sold out items?

We do restock most items.  Maymay Made It stamp sets that are not in the Vault category are always restocked.  Christmas Stamp Sets are brought back in July of each year.  For items that are ordered from other companies, we will carry them if they are not discontinued or the popularity of the item does not change.

Can I pre order new or soon to be released items?

Not at this time, we currently do not operate with pre orders.  Maymay is always afraid something will happen and we will not receive the items or the amount that we ordered may be adjusted without our knowledge and that would be a nightmare!

Why am I charged taxes?

If you live in Alabama (Roll Tide from Vinnie) then you will be charged the applicable State, County, City taxes.

My order is lost or missing, what happens now?

In most cases we can track down the package, we ask that you contact info@maymaymadeit.com to start the process.  We aren't responsible for lost packages but we will do all we can to insure your package gets to you.  

 

How can I get notification of when a product is back in stock?

If you set up a free account on www.maymaymadeit.com and see that the product is sold out, it will prompt you to put in your email address, then when a product is restocked you will be sent an email to that address letting you know the product is back.

 

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Birthday Club
  • Card Ministry
  • Contact Us
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Shipping Procedure
  • Return Policy
  • Angel Policy
Country/region
Country/region

© 2025 Maymay Made It
Powered by Shopify

Follow Us

We Accept

American Express Apple Pay Diners Club Discover JCB Mastercard PayPal Shop Pay Venmo Visa

© 2025 Maymay Made It
Powered by Shopify

  • Opens in a new window.